Beyond the Rct - Understanding the Relationship Between Interventions, Individuals and Outcome - the Example of Neurological Rehabilitation

Kersten, P
Ellis-Hill, C
McPherson, KM
Harrington, R
Item type
Journal Article
Degree name
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Informa Healthcare Ltd.

Background Rehabilitation is highly complex, involving multiple processes, outcomes, and stakeholders. The way we deliver our services and work with our clients and their families, should be informed by research approaches that produce the wide range of knowledge needed. This paper aims to explore the degree to which the dominant approach to ‘evidence’ (the randomised clinical trial or RCT) meets those needs and discuss alternate/additional ways of gaining evidence.

Methods A critical review of the literature allowing exploration of problems encountered in rehabilitation RCTs and alterative approaches.

Findings We discuss some problematic issues related to using RCTs in rehabilitation research (for example the large number of people excluded from trials, and the small numbers of people with some neurological conditions making RCTs non viable). Alternative approaches are discussed including Clinical Practice Improvement studies (sometimes called Practice Based Evidence or PBE), which provide data on patients treated in routine practice; qualitative research, which can provide an understanding of the users of health care services to ensure they are meeting their needs; and metasynthesis, which can be used to summarise several qualitative studies to enhance our understanding of the principles underlying service delivery. Finally we explore how clinicians and commissioners often use evidence generated by forms of research other than the RCT.

Conclusion 2 The best answers about how to enhance rehabilitation outcomes are likely to come from a combination and integration of the most appropriate methods. In conclusion, we urge for more joined up thinking, for learning from different fields so that we can develop more effective and appropriate health care and rehabilitation.

Rehabilitation , Rehabilitation medicine , Physiotherapy , Occupational therapy , Speech and language therapy , Clinical psychology , Rehabilitation nursing , Evidence-based medicine , Poststroke-rehabilitation , Cochrane collaboration , Clinical-practice , Black-box , Stroke , Guidelines , Therapy , Trials , Policy
Disability and Rehabilitation, vol.32(12), pp.1028 - 1034
Rights statement
Copyright © Informa Healthcare, 2010. Authors retain the right to place his/her post-publication version of the work on a personal website or institutional repository for non commercial purposes. The definitive version was published in (see Citation). The original publication is available at (see Publisher's Version)