AUT LibraryAUT
View Item 
  •   Open Research
  • AUT Faculties
  • Faculty of Business, Economics and Law
  • AUT Business School
  • View Item
  •   Open Research
  • AUT Faculties
  • Faculty of Business, Economics and Law
  • AUT Business School
  • View Item
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Evidence, Interests and Argumentation: An Environmental Policy Controversy in a Small New Zealand Town

Skilling, P; Barrett, P; Kurian, P
Thumbnail
View/Open
Journal article (389.3Kb)
Permanent link
http://hdl.handle.net/10292/15137
Metadata
Show full metadata
Abstract
This article examines interactions between different forms of authoritative knowledge and evidence in a public dispute over an environmental problem. It draws on a case set in a small coastal town in New Zealand where the local community had expressed concern over the degradation of a river-mouth estuary caused by catchment management works built in the 1950s to support the farming sector. The estuary historically had been an important economic and cultural treasure for Indigenous Māori, and by the mid-20th century had become a valued recreational and fishing resource for the broader community. This article analyses a moment of dispute in the 1980s between those who called for the restoration of the estuary and those who wished to maintain the status quo. Drawing on an analysis of official reports, media coverage and other public documents, the article shows how the competing parties and their constructions of the collective good accorded authority and weight to specific histories, forms of evidence and kinds of people. The article understands the case not as a dispute between “the people” and “the experts” but rather as a moment where competing blocs drew on specific grammars of justification in their attempts to align their claims with the collective good.
Keywords
Expertise; Policy argumentation; Pragmatic sociology; Environmental policy
Date
December 30, 2021
Source
International Review of Public Policy [Online], 3.3 | 2021, Online since 15 March 2021, connection on 17 May 2022. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/irpp/1688; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/irpp.1688
Item Type
Journal Article
Publisher
OpenEdition
DOI
10.4000/irpp.1688
Publisher's Version
https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/1688
Rights Statement
International Review of Public Policy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.

Contact Us
  • Admin

Hosted by Tuwhera, an initiative of the Auckland University of Technology Library

 

 

Browse

Open ResearchTitlesAuthorsDateAUT Business SchoolTitlesAuthorsDate

Alternative metrics

 

Statistics

For this itemFor all Open Research

Share

 
Follow @AUT_SC

Contact Us
  • Admin

Hosted by Tuwhera, an initiative of the Auckland University of Technology Library